All posts by lsmescall


MESCALL & ACOSTA, PC, is complying with CDC recommendations and State of New Jersey regulations and working remotely.   To contact us, we are available by phone or email:

West Orange Office


Union City Office


Maximilian J. Mescall, Esq., joins M&A, PC

Mescall & Acosta, PC, is pleased to announce the addition of our new Associate, Maximilian J. Mescall, Esq.   Having graduated from Rutgers University magna cum laude with a double major in History and Political Science, Max received his Juris Doctor, cum laude, from Seton Hall University School of Law.  While at Seton Hall Law, he received numerous honors, including serving on the Editorial Board of the Seton Hall Law Review and as a Leadership Fellow and competing on the Seton Hall Interscholastic Moot Court Team.  He has served as a Judicial Intern for The Honorable Stuart Rabner, Chief Justice of The Supreme Court of New Jersey, and, most recently, as Judicial Clerk for The Honorable Scott J. Moynihan of the Appellate Division of The Superior Court of New Jersey.


Juris Doctor, Seton Hall University School of Law, 2018

Bachelor of Arts, Rutgers University, 2014


Maximilian J. Mescall, Make Campaign Coverage Great Again: Presidential Campaigns, the Press and the Right of Access, 48 SETON HALL L. REV. 1653 (2018)

John Kelly and Maximilian J. Mescall, Taking Stock of the Block: Blockchain, Corporate Stock Ledgers and Delaware General Corporations Law, 1 J. OF ROBOTICS, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE & LAW 145, 235 (2018)


New Jersey Association for Justice

New Jersey State Bar Association, Young Lawyers Division

Essex County Bar Association


$700,000.00 settlement in truck-auto accident

On Monday, July 10, 2017, James Mescall secured a settlement of $700,000 on a case filed in Essex County.    He represented a 46-year-old woman who had one level cervical fusion surgery more than four years after a motor vehicle accident. She was driving to work on Route 22 in Newark when she attempted to pass a truck, traveling in the middle lane, on the right. The tractor (bob-tail) began to move into the right lane to exit the highway, causing a minor collision. The property damage to the plaintiff’s vehicle was approximately $800. The truck had no damage. The defense retained John Desch, an accident reconstruction expert, who claimed the “Delta V” was less than 5 mph.  Defendant’s biomechanical expert, Ronald Fijalkowski, claimed that the cervical herniation could not have been caused by the minor impact. Dr. Albert Thrower opined, for the defense, that plaintiff had a “degenerative disc osteophyte complex” which predated the collision. Plaintiff had not returned to work as longshoreman following the accident. Plaintiff had a significant lost wage claim and there was an ERISA lien. The case was settled with the assistance of Judge Robert Gardner. There were motions pending to strike the opinions of the defendant’s accident reconstruction expert and biomechanical expert based primarily on the faulty methodology employed in calculating the “Delta V”. The case was settled before those motions were decided.

ATV Safety

All Terrain Vehicles (ATVs) are powerful, fast, open vehicles that enthusiasts find fun and exhilarating. However, without the proper safety and regulatory precautions, drivers, especially those under the age of 16, can be in serious danger. Discover safety guidelines by reading our newsletter.

James Mescall to Argue Before New Jersey Supreme Court

The firm procured a $1 million dollar settlement for its client. However, one issue in the case remains to be decided by the Supreme Court of New Jersey in Johnson vs. Roselle EZ Quick, LLC, et. al., Docket #: 07504.

Karon Johnson, who was 20 years old, purchased a bottle of vodka from a liquor store. He drank the liquor and ran his vehicle through a fence and into a tree receiving serious injuries and becoming paralyzed from the waist down. Since he was allowed to purchase alcohol despite being underaged, the firm asserted a claim against the package store. There were no witnesses to the purchase, and Johnson did not have a receipt. Any video of the transaction was recycled prior to the date the firm was retained to represent Johnson. The liquor store denied making the sale. However, the firm’s investigation revealed several people who had purchased liquor, while underage, from the same liquor store. The insurance company for the defendant offered the full liquor liability policy, in the amount of $1,000,000.00 in settlement which Johnson agreed to accept. However, Geico Insurance Company which provided no-fault medical insurance covering the vehicle Johnson was operating at the time of the accident, had paid $250,000.00 of Johnson’s medical bills. Geico asserted a claim to “claw back” the $250,000.00 in medical benefits paid from the settlement proceeds, pursuant to N.J.S.A. 39:6A-9.1. The disputed funds were placed in escrow pending the Court’s determination of the issue.

After Johnson’s accident the New Jersey Legislature amended the law to prevent a no-fault insurer from “clawing back” no-fault benefits where an injured person was not “fully compensated” by the available liability insurance proceeds. The Legislature did not explicitly indicate whether the statutory amendment applied to cases which were pending or only to “new” accidents which occurred after the date the amendment was passed into law. After obtaining transcripts of the legislative hearings Mescall & Acosta argued that the Legislature intended the amendment to be “retroactive” and apply to cases which were pending, such as Johnson’s, at the time the amendment became law. The case has proceed through both the Law Division and the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court. Mescall & Acosta and counsel for Geico have both filed their briefs with the New Jersey Supreme Court. It is expected that the Supreme Court will hear arguments in the Spring of 2015 and decide the case. If Mescall & Acosta prevail, Mr. Johnson will receive his entire settlement which will be placed into a “Special Needs Trust” to assist in paying for the ongoing care which his medical condition requires.